ANTI-sedevacantist controversialist and SSPX apologist Robert Siscoe thinks he has found a killer argument against the sedevacantist position: Gregory IX promulgated an evil universal disciplinary law in 1234, but remained a true pope! Bingo! This lets Paul VI (who promulgated the New Mass) and JP2 (who promulgated the new Code of Canon Law) off the […]
Friday, February 24, 2017
OK, MR. OR MRS. TRAD — you always tell your Novus Ordo friends how bad “Vatican II” was. But can you actually give them examples of the Council’s main errors? Matthew Arthur and True Restoration to the rescue! They’ve put together a snappy, two-and-a-half minute video that briefly lists and explains the errors for you. Send […]
Tuesday, February 21, 2017
IN FALL of 2016, Messrs. Salza and Siscoe published a 25,000- word response to my video Dead on Arrival, in which they attempted to explain away their earlier and egregious mixup of basic theological terms and to enlist the writings of Louis Cardinal Billot against the sedevacantist position. A Dignified Burial makes short work of […]
IN JANUARY 2016, the Society of St. Pius X published a 700-page book touted as the definitive refutation of sedevacantism and the ultimate vindication of the “recognize-and-resist” (R&R) position, John Salza and Robert Siscoe’s True or False Pope. When it first appeared, I thought it would merit a series of videos that would allow me to […]
Filed in Francis / Bergoglio, Sedevacantism, Sedevacantism: Objections, SSPX: Errors, Trad Controversies
|
Tagged Bergoglio, Francis / Bergoglio, John Salza, Robert Siscoe, sedevacantism, Society of St. Pius X, SSPX, True or False Pope?
|
Correct answer: A. Answered B or C? Oops! You need to review Pius XII’s teaching on the sin of heresy and membership in the Church, in addition to Boniface VIII’s teaching on submission to the Roman Pontiff as necessary for salvation! Support our Internet apostolate! For info, click here
Filed in Francis / Bergoglio, Sedevacantism, SSPX: Errors
|
Tagged Anthony Cekada, Francis / Bergoglio, Salza, sedevacantism, sedevacantists, Siscoe, Society of St. Pius X, SSPX, True or False Pope?
|
In the Preface to my book on the New Mass, Work of Human Hands, I mention that the bad music that invaded the liturgy almost immediately after the liturgical changes began in the 1960s prompted me to study music — specifically, organ, choral conducting and musical composition. I was blessed to have studied under some excellent teachers. More […]
Saturday, February 27, 2016
Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre made many statements that support sedevacantism, the theological position held by Catholic traditionalists who believe that the Vatican II popes were not true popes, due to public heresy. Father Anthony Cekada, a priest who was a seminarian in SSPX’s early days and who personally knew the archbishop, provides a selection of these […]
Filed in Lefebvre, Sedevacantism, Sedevacantism: Objections, SSPX: Errors, Trad Controversies
|
Tagged Anthony Cekada, Lefebvre, Robert Siscoe, Salza, sedevacantism, Society of St. Pius X, SSPX, True or False Pope?
|
Wednesday, February 10, 2016
This is a short video taking on SSPX’s two anti-sedevacantist musketeers, John Salza and Robert Siscoe, authors of True or False Pope, as SSPX-bankrolled screed against sedevacantism. To support the R&R theory that a heretical pope would not automatically lose his office, Messrs. Salza and Siscoe point to the case of Nestorius — only to be clobbered […]
Wednesday, February 10, 2016
CANDLEMAS or the Feast of the Purification on February 2 is always solemnly celebrated at St. Gertrude the Great with either a Pontifical or a Solemn High Mass, preceded by the striking ceremony of the Blessing of Candles and Procession. We are pleased to present excerpts from our choir’s outstanding selection of music for the […]
Wednesday, February 10, 2016
AN EXAMINATION of the Society of St. Pius X’s charge that sedevacantism produces “bitter fruit,” which some claims “disproves” its theological reasoning. Historical perspective: conflict among Catholics where in situations where authority could not be effectively exercised. Conflict withing non-sedevacantist traditionalist movement in the United States. A history of the internal turmoil, division and other “bitter fruit” […]
Filed in Sedevacantism, Sedevacantism: Objections, SSPX: Misc, Trad Controversies
|
Tagged Anthony Cekada, Bishop Fellay, Remnant Newspaper, Robert Siscoe, Salza, sedevacantism, Siscoe, True or False Pope?
|